Two Men, No Uteruses (Steven Waldman & William Saletan)

[mmacklem]

Originally Posted by Me&theboys

Well, first, as should be evident from my post, I'm open to someone making a good argument (rather than a hypothetical one) for why what those two have to say is more relevant than (or as relevant as) the views of the kinds of people I listed. Second, I've read enough of Saletan to feel he's too committed to personal view expression over pure reporting when it comes to this topic. Would prefer to hear it from the horse's mouth than filtered through Satelan's third party thrice removed brain.

My mistake then. I had mistaken your post for one of those "Here's two male columnists who have no right to say anything on this topic" criticisms, which I find so frustrating. Personally, I also find Saletan frustrating at times, but at other times his writing seems to be closest to where I find myself in this debate, so I do find him interesting more often than not. But I can definitely see other's frustrations with him.