Go Back   Bloggingheads Community > Diavlog comments
FAQ Members List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Notices

Diavlog comments Post comments about particular diavlogs here.
(Users cannot create new threads.)

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 10-26-2008, 05:28 PM
Bloggingheads Bloggingheads is offline
BhTV staff
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 1,936
Default Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 10-26-2008, 07:48 PM
travis68 travis68 is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 44
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

Nice diavlog. It's great to have Will to abstract out the various arguments since he brings such clarity.

There are two parts that I don't get:

1) The first part where the moral reason to help someone is independent of a desire to help someone.

2) The last part where the reasons determining the weighting function aren't explained, but Mark says that his explanation rests on a similar explanation given in the first part -- see above. But that's the part I didn't understand.

Mark seems to want to resist Will's pushing of the cultural relativity among moral reasons. If they talk again, I wish Will would push him more on that topic.

It seems that human beings are both wired socially and individualistically. We don't want to be outcasts in society but at the same time we tend to resist social demands that will result in self-immolation.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 10-26-2008, 09:45 PM
fedorovingtonboop fedorovingtonboop is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 216
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

don't everyone get mad at me because i'm trying to be (sort of) gentle...
here it is: not-a-lotta substance (or comments.) i'll stop there
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 10-27-2008, 12:55 AM
Bloggin' Noggin Bloggin' Noggin is offline
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 893
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

Thanks to Will and BloggingHeads for hosting a discussion that's liable to have so very small an audience! I enjoyed this. Mark did a nice job of explaining how he keeps his theory of reasons from implying an excessive self-involvement. He does seem to get rather hand-wavy where he tries to explain the connection to moral reasons -- particularly, as Travis points out, when he gets to his recursive theory of the weighting of reasons etc. Still that's to be expected in a conversation like this -- it whets one's appetite for the book. Unfortunately the book is too expensive even in the Kindle edition! Well, who knows? I did download the free sample -- maybe that will tempt me further.

I do wish Will would try to provide a bit more of a foil for his guests, even when he feels he's in broad agreement with the guest. For example, here are two questions that would have helped clarify where Mark stands for me:
1. If all reasons are based in desires, does that mean that I don't have a reason until I have the desire? To use Thomas Nagel's example, suppose I know I'll be hungry tomorrow, though I'm quite full (and even quite lethargic) right now. Does my future desire give me reason to go shopping now? Or must there be some further desire for my own future satisfaction which gives me reason now? And would there be anything irrational about lacking such a desire for my own future satisfaction?
2. Isn't it possible to satisfy one of my desires without bringing satisfaction or fulfullment to me? I might want (or think I want) fame above everything, yet, when I get it, realize that that wasn't really what I wanted at all. It seems that I got what I wanted, but in such a case, is it really true that I had reason to pursue it? (This is related to the Dr. Pepper/gasoline example, yet it doesn't seem so easy to say how I was wrong about the nature of fame -- except to restate that it is something that after all doesn't satisfy me in the way I expected.) Humeans take desires as primitive -- things that can explain reason without needing to be explained in terms of reasons. I think problems like this make that seem much less clear. Don't we desire many things because we think them good?

Or Will might have done more to challenge Mark's assuption that Humeanism is more naturalistic than alternative theories (at least we could have heard a bit about alternative theories...). Insofar as a Humean attempts a normative theory of reasons, he seems to have accepted at least some categorical imperatives ("you ought rationally to do that which promotes your ends (even if you have no motivation to promote your ends"). If categorical imperatives of that sort are acceptable, then why couldn't a categorical imperative to pursue ones own interest be naturalistically acceptable? And if that sort of categorical imperative is acceptable, why not Kant's version?

Still, it was an intriguing discussion.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 10-27-2008, 02:21 AM
bjkeefe bjkeefe is offline
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Not Real America, according to St. SaŽah
Posts: 21,798
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bloggin' Noggin View Post
Thanks to Will and BloggingHeads for hosting a discussion that's liable to have so very small an audience! I enjoyed this.
I was going to gripe about yetanotherdiavlogonmorality, but if you're happy, I'm happy.
__________________
Brendan
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 10-27-2008, 03:14 AM
MikeDrew MikeDrew is offline
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 110
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

Wisconsin! Represent!
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 10-27-2008, 03:55 AM
MikeDrew MikeDrew is offline
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 110
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

I have never seen how moral facts could be embedded in a materialistic world. I therefore have always looked at morality as an invention of human civilization and consciousness. If Mark has an account of the metaphysics of morality that situates comfortably in a materialsitic, mechanistic world, I would be very interested indeed.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 10-27-2008, 03:35 PM
Francoamerican
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

Shall I go dancing? Shall I be a rockstar? Shall I be a philosopher? Shall I help Katy?

Help Katy! If you really cannot understand why your reason(s) for helping Katy are moral reasons whereas your reason(s) for being a rockstar or a dancer or a philosopher have nothing to do with morality, then, I would suggest, you are not yet a philosopher, or at least not yet moral! When Hume said that Reason was, and ought to be, the slave of the passions, he wasn't saying that all reasons for action are on the same plane; he was simply saying that what motivates us to be good (or virtuous) has nothing to do with knowledge of fact (science) or knowledge of relations (mathematics), but with the sentiments (passions) that certain situations arouse in us. I believe Hume was mistaken, but he was certainly right about one thing: morality is something other than whim.

Last edited by Francoamerican; 10-27-2008 at 03:44 PM..
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 10-27-2008, 05:36 PM
Me&theboys Me&theboys is offline
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 447
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

are you enjoying your Kindle?
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 10-28-2008, 07:32 PM
schumacher schumacher is offline
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Posts: 8
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

I like both of these guys,but i found this very hard to understand.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 10-28-2008, 08:07 PM
Bloggin' Noggin Bloggin' Noggin is offline
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 893
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

Quote:
Originally Posted by Me&theboys View Post
are you enjoying your Kindle?
Love it, love it, love it! Only problem: your book is not just a book but a whole book store, and it's awfully easy to get distracted from the book you're reading by all the books you might be buying. I assume you're still enjoying yours as well?
I haven't yet given in, but I'm actually somewhat tempted to shell out the 54 dollars for the Kindle edition of Mark's book. The little bit they give you as a sample was pretty good. But just think of how many times I could go dancing (if I wanted to) rather than buy that book!
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 10-30-2008, 06:26 PM
Me&theboys Me&theboys is offline
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 447
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bloggin' Noggin View Post
Love it, love it, love it! Only problem: your book is not just a book but a whole book store, and it's awfully easy to get distracted from the book you're reading by all the books you might be buying. I assume you're still enjoying yours as well?
I haven't yet given in, but I'm actually somewhat tempted to shell out the 54 dollars for the Kindle edition of Mark's book. The little bit they give you as a sample was pretty good. But just think of how many times I could go dancing (if I wanted to) rather than buy that book!
Me, too. I find I am loading mine up with lots of samples (a great marketing tactic) and PDFs of papers I want to read, which is far better than dragging around lots of 8.5x11 paper. I also thought about buying mark's book - mostly because Will seemed so enamored with it, so I figured that there must be more substance to the arguments in the book than Mark conveyed in the diavlog. He reverted too often to non-moral decision examples when making claims about moral decisions, which I found frustrating. If you buy it, let me know what you think of it. If not, have fun dancing!
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 10-31-2008, 12:12 PM
Uhurusasa Uhurusasa is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 117
Default Re: Free Will: You Should Dance If You Want To

the more thoughts i hear on thinking, the more i long to hear the unthought thinking on the subject!! then too, maybe i just haven't been exposed to the greater body of thought? or, perhaps, in this regard, i am on a journey without a destination.

Last edited by Uhurusasa; 10-31-2008 at 12:29 PM..
Reply With Quote
 


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:06 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.