Go Back   Bloggingheads Community > Diavlog comments
FAQ Members List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Notices

Diavlog comments Post comments about particular diavlogs here.
(Users cannot create new threads.)

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 05-30-2011, 12:03 AM
Bloggingheads Bloggingheads is offline
BhTV staff
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 1,936
Default Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 05-30-2011, 01:31 AM
whyjoshua whyjoshua is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 7
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Love to hear Melinda Henneberger! Looking forward to this diavlog.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 05-30-2011, 07:32 PM
Abdicate Abdicate is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Eden Prairie, Minnesota
Posts: 90
Send a message via Yahoo to Abdicate Send a message via Skype™ to Abdicate
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

The assertion that Democrats connived to get Jon Huntsman out of the country in order to remove a feared political opponent might benefit from evidence.

Henneberger and Sullivan snicker about prevailing anti-Mormon prejudice, while displaying resigned acceptance of anti-atheist prejudice.

Henneberger quotes Jackie O, but 'I don't think she said that publicly at the time.' Please, Ms. Henneberger: Provide a citation in which Jackie O ever made this statement [that JFK was a bad Catholic].

Sullivan claims hearing Howard Dean talk about how he left his church over a bike path. Please, Ms. Sullivan: Provide a citation in which Howard Dean publicly makes this assertion.

Sullivan: 'The more you hear about Mormon theology the more likely you are to think this is absolutely not part of my religion.' IOW--Sullivan's political thinking assumes adherence to mainline/evangelical Christianity; she has no desire to take a religiously-neutral perspective.

When you hear someone say, 'This election is one in which the economy will play a particularly prominent role,' you really have to re-evaluate your belief that you're not smart enough to appear on Bloggingheads.

Henneberger: Don't all our faiths sound a bit cultish to someone outside the faith? Certainly: Yes. Funny that Henneberger is aware of this damning insight--and assumes brushing it aside is honorable. Odd.

On leaving office, GWB admitted he is a religious liberal. (GWB accepts evolution and does not believe the Bible to be literally true.) It is surprising how many people still refer to GWB as 'a religious conservative'--even though we now know that he isn't: He's a politician who successfully passed himself off as a religious conservative.

Yes, Ms. Henneberger: GWB wore his religion on his sleeve. He successfully hoodwinked stupid people. That's correct.

Henneberger: Faith has become a proxy for Can I trust this guy? IOW, non-believers and non-Christians--to Henneberger--just have to accept their eternal second-class-citizenship.

Both Sullivan and Henneberger are constantly fudging, then, their role as neutral observer with their own approval of religion's political uses. Both hold politically-favored religious views and consider the perpetuation of said favoritism their birthright.

Can anybody find a link for the anti-Harkin ad, with the priest, to which Amy refers?

Amy Sullivan: [Ayn Rand] was just incredibly anti-religion. We're not required to like religion, are we? Why should Sullivan feel so comfortable in suggesting that opposition to religion should require apology? Henneberger, approving, again: '...Rand and Rome really don't go together...' [!]

Sullivan and Henneberger note that the media pay great attention to the Catholic Church's teaching on abortion but disregard the Church's liberal social-justice teachings.

Catholics themselves also make this 'error': If you ask Catholics what the most important political position advocated by their church is, you'll get abortion/pro-life. (The Catholic church I attend sponsors bus trips to anti-abortion rallies--and never to anti-poverty rallies.) This isn't a media misperception, in short--it's a reality that deserves being reported straightforwardly.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 05-31-2011, 12:48 PM
Abu Noor Al-Irlandee Abu Noor Al-Irlandee is offline
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Chicago
Posts: 392
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Henneberger quotes Jackie O, but 'I don't think she said that publicly at the time.' Please, Ms. Henneberger: Provide a citation in which Jackie O ever made this statement [that JFK was a bad Catholic].
This is quoted in Garry Wills' book "The Kennedy Imprisonment" where it is said that Ms. Kennedy said to Arthur Krock, "I think it is unfair for Jack to be opposed because he is a Catholic. After all, he's such a poor Catholic. Now if it were Bobby: he never misses mass and prays all the time."

http://books.google.com/books?id=Kve...tholic&f=false
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 05-31-2011, 08:15 PM
look look is offline
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 2,886
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Abu Noor Al-Irlandee View Post
This is quoted in Garry Wills' book "The Kennedy Imprisonment" where it is said that Ms. Kennedy said to Arthur Krock, "I think it is unfair for Jack to be opposed because he is a Catholic. After all, he's such a poor Catholic. Now if it were Bobby: he never misses mass and prays all the time."

http://books.google.com/books?id=Kve...tholic&f=false
Greetings, Abu Noor.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 06-01-2011, 01:46 PM
Abdicate Abdicate is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Eden Prairie, Minnesota
Posts: 90
Send a message via Yahoo to Abdicate Send a message via Skype™ to Abdicate
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Thanks very much for taking the time to read my post, Abu Noor.

Oh--okay--JFK is a bad Catholic in the sense that he doesn't uncritically accept all Catholic theology, doesn't attend Mass every Sunday and doesn't recite prayers with acceptable roteness.

Today it is more widely acknowledged that there is extreme diversity in belief, among Catholics--and that almost no one accepts church teaching hook, line and sinker.

Once you disagree with the Catholic Church on any tenet, you have no right to malign a coreligionist a cafeteria Catholic.

The sense in which Jackie O is said to have called JFK 'a bad Catholic', then, lends itself to easy confusion today, since almost no one uses the phrase that way anymore.

Last edited by Abdicate; 06-01-2011 at 02:14 PM.. Reason: beat the devil
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 06-01-2011, 01:55 PM
stephanie stephanie is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 3,921
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Abdicate View Post
Oh--okay--Kennedy is 'a bad Catholic' in the sense that he doesn't uncritically accept all Catholic theology, doesn't attend Mass every Sunday and doesn't recite prayers with acceptable roteness. (That's the context in which your citation is sandwiched.)
I don't think that's clearly the meaning of the quote. Nor do I think that was Melinda's point.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 06-01-2011, 03:12 PM
Abdicate Abdicate is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Eden Prairie, Minnesota
Posts: 90
Send a message via Yahoo to Abdicate Send a message via Skype™ to Abdicate
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
I don't think that's clearly the meaning of the quote. Nor do I think that was Melinda's point.
[said Stephanie]

Here's the quotation [from The Kennedy Imprisonment] whose meaning Stephanie and I dispute:

Quote:
Theodore Sorensen vouched for the fact that ‘[JFK] cared not a whit for theology.’ Jacqueline Kennedy told Arthur Krock: ‘I think it is unfair for Jack to be opposed because he is a Catholic. After all, he’s such a poor Catholic. Now if it were Bobby: he never misses mass and prays all the time’
Within the diavlog, Melinda Henneberger suggests Jon Huntsman--once he decides what religion he is--'would be hurt by taking the Kennedy line from 1960, remember, when Jackie Kennedy said to a friend, ‘It’s so unfair when they hold Jack’s Catholic faith against him when he’s such a poor Catholic.’

IOW, Henneberger wasn't really making any point, with the allusion: No participant could conceivably be suggesting such an option to Huntsman, nor did Kennedy himself employ the narrative as any candidacy-advancing meme.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 06-01-2011, 03:36 PM
stephanie stephanie is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 3,921
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Abdicate View Post
IOW, Henneberger wasn't really making any point, with the allusion: No participant could conceivably be suggesting such an option to Huntsman, nor did Kennedy himself employ the narrative as any candidacy-advancing meme.
Melinda's point (to put it more seriously than she did) was that a candidate who is of a religion that makes people uncomfortable in part due to their suspicion that the candidate might be extremely devout is nonetheless in a bind, since no candidate for president in the US can say "oh, yeah, but I'm not really religious," even if that's true.

Her suggestion was that many people would be comforted to know that a Catholic candidate was only a cultural Catholic (less so now than then, but not incorrect among some even now) or Huntsman (or some other Mormon candidate) only a cultural Mormon. (Note: I'm not claiming Huntsman is. I have no idea. I do think there's reason to think JFK may not have been all that religious, although I don't care either way.)

I'm sure that for someone, especially someone not all that interested in politics or in tune with middle America (as seems to have been the case with Jackie Kennedy), holding supposed super-devoutness (in the Catholic sense, given the fears of the day, that one would take orders from the Pope) against a candidate for whom that was simply a worry inconsistent with how he led his life, would seem crazy and unfair. Thus, the statement and why it's kind of humorous (whether true or not, although I don't see any reason that Garry Wills couldn't be trusted here).

Melinda didn't suggest that JFK "took this line," btw. Her point was that neither of them could, even if it were in fact true.

The reason I disagree with your interpretation of the quote (although that's less significant to what I think we are talking about) is that I see nothing in it to suggest that Jackie is saying that disagreement with the Church on anything or, especially, a lack of sufficiently rote prayer (who said Jackie thought prayer should be rote?) is the issue.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 05-30-2011, 08:24 PM
carkrueger carkrueger is offline
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 93
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote from Obama which he has used several times.

"And recognizing that my fate remain tied up with their fates, that my individual salvation is not going to come about without a collective salvation for the country."

Collective salvation is not a tenant of Christianity it's a tenant of Marxism.

Amy claims that Obama gave the best Christian testimony she's ever heard, better then that Evangelical Bush. I reviewed his prayer breakfast speech and their was no testimony. I've never heard Obama tell the story of being lost and turning his life and his will over to Jesus Christ. That's what a testimony is!

I like Bill Maher don't believe he's a Christian or a Muslim but rather an atheist. And if Americans can put an atheist into the White House why not a Mormon?
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 05-30-2011, 08:51 PM
Don Zeko Don Zeko is offline
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Exiled to South Jersey
Posts: 2,436
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by carkrueger View Post
Quote from Obama which he has used several times.

"And recognizing that my fate remain tied up with their fates, that my individual salvation is not going to come about without a collective salvation for the country."
I only have the stomach to read through the first three pages of results for a google search of that quote, but none of the first three dozen results included links to any sources other than Glenn Back's show. Given that, I'm not going to assert as fact that Obama never said this, but I'd say that there's a strong circumstantial case that this quote was either taken out of context, doctored, or fabricated since it hasn't appeared in any reputable news source.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 05-30-2011, 09:20 PM
Wonderment Wonderment is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Southern California
Posts: 5,694
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
I'm not going to assert as fact that Obama never said this, but I'd say that there's a strong circumstantial case that this quote was either taken out of context, doctored, or fabricated since it hasn't appeared in any reputable news source.
Published here in Time Magazine by Barack Obama::

Quote:
For one thing, I was drawn to the power of the African American religious tradition to spur social change. Out of necessity, the black church had to minister to the whole person. Out of necessity, the black church rarely had the luxury of separating individual salvation from collective salvation. It had to serve as the center of the community's political, economic, and social as well as spiritual life; it understood in an intimate way the biblical call to feed the hungry and clothe the naked and challenge powers and principalities. In the history of these struggles, I was able to see faith as more than just a comfort to the weary or a hedge against death; rather, it was an active, palpable agent in the world.
__________________
Seek Peace and Pursue it
בקש שלום ורדפהו
Busca la paz y síguela
--Psalm 34:15
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 05-30-2011, 09:25 PM
Ocean Ocean is offline
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: US Northeast
Posts: 6,784
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wonderment View Post
Published here in Time Magazine by Barack Obama::
His quote and the topic in general reminds me of Liberation Theology.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 05-30-2011, 11:15 PM
eeeeeeeli eeeeeeeli is offline
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Palm Desert, CA
Posts: 811
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ocean View Post
His quote and the topic in general reminds me of Liberation Theology.
Or just human decency.

But people who celebrate getting ahead by pushing others down wouldn't understand that.
__________________
my blog
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 05-31-2011, 11:45 AM
stephanie stephanie is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 3,921
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ocean View Post
His quote and the topic in general reminds me of Liberation Theology.
The quote, with the context Wonderment provided, is consistent with significant threads of Christian theology (not to mention writing in the Old Testament which many evangelicals, among others, tend to take seriously). If Beck was trying to claim Obama was insufficiently orthodox or some such (a silly claim for a Mormon to make), I think Beck is inadequately educated or something worse.
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 05-31-2011, 12:13 PM
operative operative is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 3,261
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by stephanie View Post
The quote, with the context Wonderment provided, is consistent with significant threads of Christian theology (not to mention writing in the Old Testament which many evangelicals, among others, tend to take seriously). If Beck was trying to claim Obama was insufficiently orthodox or some such (a silly claim for a Mormon to make), I think Beck is inadequately educated or something worse.
Admittedly I'm no expert on theology, but from what I can gather, much of more modern theology presents a very individualistic interpretation of the message of salvation--hence all of the rhetoric about Christ being one's personal savior, as opposed to some sort of community savior (this is perhaps an outgrowth of the spread of Christianity across disparate communities, as opposed to the relative homogeneity of the Jewish community).

I find the notion of collective salvation to be rather creepy. It's a gateway to authoritarian policies, as it places the community above the individual and defines the role of the individual only as part of the collective.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 05-31-2011, 12:24 PM
miceelf miceelf is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 2,569
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by operative View Post
Admittedly I'm no expert on theology, but from what I can gather, much of more modern theology presents a very individualistic interpretation of the message of salvation--hence all of the rhetoric about Christ being one's personal savior, as opposed to some sort of community savior (this is perhaps an outgrowth of the spread of Christianity across disparate communities, as opposed to the relative homogeneity of the Jewish community).

I find the notion of collective salvation to be rather creepy. It's a gateway to authoritarian policies, as it places the community above the individual and defines the role of the individual only as part of the collective.
Well, one man's "modern theology" is another man's "heresy."

of course you find it creepy. I find the prosperity gospel creepy. Our religious preferences and our political preferences are probably quite strongly linked to each other.
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 05-31-2011, 12:52 PM
operative operative is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 3,261
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by miceelf View Post
Well, one man's "modern theology" is another man's "heresy."
Sure, but there's a general direction that Christian theology went, that coincided with the advent of modern democracy, inalienable rights, and economic dynamism, and I'd say that's the individualistic approach. The collective approach is a definite rebellion against that.

Quote:
of course you find it creepy. I find the prosperity gospel creepy. Our religious preferences and our political preferences are probably quite strongly linked to each other.
Personally I find the prosperity gospel to just be a little silly. It seems to be a natural offspring of Weber, though.
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 05-31-2011, 02:28 PM
miceelf miceelf is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 2,569
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by operative View Post
Sure, but there's a general direction that Christian theology went, that coincided with the advent of modern democracy, inalienable rights, and economic dynamism, and I'd say that's the individualistic approach. The collective approach is a definite rebellion against that.
No, the recent passion for the free market and the downgrading of social gospel is a much more recent phenomenon within Christianity than the timeline you suggest.
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 05-31-2011, 02:33 PM
operative operative is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 3,261
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by miceelf View Post
No, the recent passion for the free market and the downgrading of social gospel is a much more recent phenomenon within Christianity than the timeline you suggest.
I'm not referring strictly to free market capitalism. I'm talking about the shift to the emphasis on the individual, which goes hand in hand with Locke and other social contract theorists who are responsible for our modern sense of individual rights and liberties.
Reply With Quote
  #21  
Old 05-31-2011, 08:31 PM
look look is offline
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 2,886
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by miceelf View Post
No, the recent passion for the free market and the downgrading of social gospel is a much more recent phenomenon within Christianity than the timeline you suggest.
I think operative is on the right track because I have read that the Calvinist Protestant Work Ethic helped fuel the thought that people were poor resulting from divine judgement, due to their iniquity, etc.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pro..._of_Capitalism

Though, overall I disagree with his individualist salvation theory. Just because the word 'collective' is used, does not mean it's referring to Marxism, but to the general theme throughout the Bible beginning with 'am I my brother's keeper.' We can none of us get through this alone, and as you care for the least of them, you care for Jesus.
Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old 05-31-2011, 09:52 PM
operative operative is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 3,261
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by look View Post
I think operative is on the right track because I have read that the Calvinist Protestant Work Ethic helped fuel the thought that people were poor resulting from divine judgement, due to their iniquity, etc.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pro..._of_Capitalism

Though, overall I disagree with his individualist salvation theory. Just because the word 'collective' is used, does not mean it's referring to Marxism, but to the general theme throughout the Bible beginning with 'am I my brother's keeper.' We can none of us get through this alone, and as you care for the least of them, you care for Jesus.
I think that it comes down to how a given individual interprets the latter part of your observation. The LDS church is very active in humanitarian work and its members tend to take seriously the responsibility to help others. But the LDS church doesn't argue for a massive welfare state on crypto-theocratic grounds--there's a separation between church and state. The problem is that people like Obama interpret Christianity as a tool for leftist redistributionism, and as a call to implement state policies that achieve the "collective salvation" notion.
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 05-31-2011, 11:04 PM
look look is offline
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 2,886
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by operative View Post
I think that it comes down to how a given individual interprets the latter part of your observation. The LDS church is very active in humanitarian work and its members tend to take seriously the responsibility to help others. But the LDS church doesn't argue for a massive welfare state on crypto-theocratic grounds--there's a separation between church and state. The problem is that people like Obama interpret Christianity as a tool for leftist redistributionism, and as a call to implement state policies that achieve the "collective salvation" notion.
This is a little tricky...here is the original quote we started with:

Quote:
For one thing, I was drawn to the power of the African American religious tradition to spur social change. Out of necessity, the black church had to minister to the whole person. Out of necessity, the black church rarely had the luxury of separating individual salvation from collective salvation. It had to serve as the center of the community's political, economic, and social as well as spiritual life; it understood in an intimate way the biblical call to feed the hungry and clothe the naked and challenge powers and principalities. In the history of these struggles, I was able to see faith as more than just a comfort to the weary or a hedge against death; rather, it was an active, palpable agent in the world.
I think this is to be understood on the level of the church as an agent of the poor, in the same way a lobbyist approaches congress on behalf of a company. For example, if there was a need for a childcare center, the church has the building and the workers, but may request funding if there is a program under which to ask. And yes, an urban church or an Applachian church may need more funds than the average church, most of which don't request funding at all, I'm guessing.

Now, would the Spirit be confined to non-governmental means? I don't think so
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 05-31-2011, 11:21 PM
miceelf miceelf is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 2,569
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by look View Post
This is a little tricky...here is the original quote we started with:

Now, would the Spirit be confined to non-governmental means? I don't think so
Well, to quote Mama Boucher, government is the devil.
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old 05-31-2011, 11:33 PM
look look is offline
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 2,886
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by miceelf View Post
Well, to quote Mama Boucher, government is the devil.
Had to look her up
Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old 05-31-2011, 01:35 PM
stephanie stephanie is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 3,921
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by miceelf View Post
Well, one man's "modern theology" is another man's "heresy."

of course you find it creepy. I find the prosperity gospel creepy. Our religious preferences and our political preferences are probably quite strongly linked to each other.
I'm not saying there's no link, but I am not quite so willing to assume that all we are talking about here with the theological discussion is political preference. I think it's perfectly possible to be theologically conservative and politically liberal, and I think that one can recognize the various strands of theology significant to Christianity (and Judaism) even if one dislikes certain of them.

The prosperity gospel as currently practiced is shallow and dumb (and rather heretical if one takes Jesus seriously, IMO). However, I do think an understanding of Christianity and its underpinnings requires an understanding of the aspects of the scriptures and thought which give rise to the prosperity gospel and similar ideas (like the icky claims by various religious right types that weather is a punishment for equal rights for gays or some such). In part because the discussion of and rejection of these ideas, for the most part, are part of a broader conversation.

Similarly, although more relevant for serious discussion of Christian theology, IMO, is the discussion of "the church" and what that means, and that clearly has a number of overlapping views, some which focus more on the collective nature than others. But I don't think that how one thinks about this is merely dependent on politics or even need implicate one's personal politics so much in order to discuss. That Christianity both focuses on a personal relationship and individual responsibility and on community and one's responsibility for those other than one's self, including suffering for the church as a whole -- is pretty clear. That people try to twist this indicated to me either dishonesty (re Beck, that doesn't shock me) or simple ignorance about Christian theology or context (which doesn't shock me either).
Reply With Quote
  #27  
Old 05-31-2011, 01:46 PM
operative operative is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 3,261
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by stephanie View Post
I'm not saying there's no link, but I am not quite so willing to assume that all we are talking about here with the theological discussion is political preference. I think it's perfectly possible to be theologically conservative and politically liberal, and I think that one can recognize the various strands of theology significant to Christianity (and Judaism) even if one dislikes certain of them.

The prosperity gospel as currently practiced is shallow and dumb (and rather heretical if one takes Jesus seriously, IMO). However, I do think an understanding of Christianity and its underpinnings requires an understanding of the aspects of the scriptures and thought which give rise to the prosperity gospel and similar ideas (like the icky claims by various religious right types that weather is a punishment for equal rights for gays or some such). In part because the discussion of and rejection of these ideas, for the most part, are part of a broader conversation.

Similarly, although more relevant for serious discussion of Christian theology, IMO, is the discussion of "the church" and what that means, and that clearly has a number of overlapping views, some which focus more on the collective nature than others. But I don't think that how one thinks about this is merely dependent on politics or even need implicate one's personal politics so much in order to discuss. That Christianity both focuses on a personal relationship and individual responsibility and on community and one's responsibility for those other than one's self, including suffering for the church as a whole -- is pretty clear. That people try to twist this indicated to me either dishonesty (re Beck, that doesn't shock me) or simple ignorance about Christian theology or context (which doesn't shock me either).
I wouldn't equate care for your fellow man (or woman) with the notion of collective salvation--not that you're necessarily trying to do that, but it's easy to reach that conclusion. The LDS church heavily emphasizes charity and service, but there's no notion of collective salvation. Members are among the most giving of time and money of any church, bt members are also the most conservative on average. There's also a difference between emphasizing private charity and wanting the government to engage in welfare state politics that mandate it.

I don't like any articulation of a political view that involves "This is what the Bible says." Whether that's those who want to have schools praying and teaching creationism, or having a crypto-theocratic redistributionist state on the basis of Biblical teachings.
Reply With Quote
  #28  
Old 05-31-2011, 02:33 PM
miceelf miceelf is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 2,569
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by stephanie View Post
I'm not saying there's no link, but I am not quite so willing to assume that all we are talking about here with the theological discussion is political preference. I think it's perfectly possible to be theologically conservative and politically liberal, and I think that one can recognize the various strands of theology significant to Christianity (and Judaism) even if one dislikes certain of them.

Oh, I wasn't meaning to imply that political preferences drive religious preferences. Just that the two tend to go together. I think the labeling of "theologically conservative" is as problematic as the politically conservative label, so whether one is theologically one and politically another is not predictable.

Forgetting about the broad labels, I was merely saying that particular theological beliefs and particular political beliefs tend to covary. So, if a big part of one's theologies is mutual concern and the old testament justice ideal, then one's political ideology is also more likely to be consonant with that.

But in short, I was NOT positiing that politics drives theology. I think vice versa is just as likely and third causes (like personality and experience) are even more likely, but my claim was of covariation, not causality.
Reply With Quote
  #29  
Old 05-31-2011, 04:36 PM
stephanie stephanie is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 3,921
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by miceelf View Post
Oh, I wasn't meaning to imply that political preferences drive religious preferences. Just that the two tend to go together.
I don't so much disagree as think it's more complicated than that allows. Of course, part of this depends on what we mean by "conservative" or "liberal" in a religious sense. I'm not comfortable with many casual applications of those terms (as you indicate below). For example, I don't see American evangelicalism as "conservative" religiously at all. It's easier to see within denominations, too.

It's true that there's been a move away in recent years from the traditional breaks between denominations to a broader split between liberal and conservative approaches (in a way that misuses the term "conservative"), but there are some groups to which this does not apply all that well, and I want to resist this anyway, since I think we are focusing on the wrong questions when it gets simplified in that way too much.

Quote:
I think the labeling of "theologically conservative" is as problematic as the politically conservative label, so whether one is theologically one and politically another is not predictable.
Yep.

Quote:
Forgetting about the broad labels, I was merely saying that particular theological beliefs and particular political beliefs tend to covary. So, if a big part of one's theologies is mutual concern and the old testament justice ideal, then one's political ideology is also more likely to be consonant with that.
Okay.
Reply With Quote
  #30  
Old 05-30-2011, 09:28 PM
TwinSwords TwinSwords is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Heartland Conservative
Posts: 4,933
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

And there is also this, from Obama's 2008 Commencement Address at Wesleyan:

Quote:
Each of you will have the chance to make your own discovery in the years to come. And I say “chance” because you won’t have to take it. There’s no community service requirement in the real world; no one forcing you to care. You can take your diploma, walk off this stage, and chase only after the big house and the nice suits and all the other things that our money culture says you should by. You can choose to narrow your concerns and live your life in a way that tries to keep your story separate from America’s.

But I hope you don’t. Not because you have an obligation to those who are less fortunate, though you do have that obligation. Not because you have a debt to all those who helped you get here, though you do have that debt.

It’s because you have an obligation to yourself. Because our individual salvation depends on collective salvation. Because thinking only about yourself, fulfilling your immediate wants and needs, betrays a poverty of ambition. Because it’s only when you hitch your wagon to something larger than yourself that you realize your true potential and discover the role you’ll play in writing the next great chapter in America’s story.

There are so many ways to serve and so much need at this defining moment in our history. You don’t have to be a community organizer or do something crazy like run for President. Right here at Wesleyan, many of you have already volunteered at local schools, contributed to United Way, and even started a program that brings fresh produce to needy families in the area. One hundred and sixty-four graduates of this school have joined the Peace Corps since 2001, and I’m especially proud that two of you are about to leave for my father’s homeland of Kenya to bring alternative sources of energy to impoverished areas.
So, Obama has talked about salvation, but we still have not found a credible source for the quote in carkrueger's post.

Last edited by TwinSwords; 05-30-2011 at 09:53 PM..
Reply With Quote
  #31  
Old 05-30-2011, 09:51 PM
TwinSwords TwinSwords is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Heartland Conservative
Posts: 4,933
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Audio of Obama making a statement similar to carkrueger's quote here, at the 2:10 point. And the exact quote can be heard at the very end of the recording.
Reply With Quote
  #32  
Old 05-30-2011, 11:42 PM
look look is offline
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 2,886
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

[QUOTE=Wonderment;211234]
Quote:
For one thing, I was drawn to the power of the African American religious tradition to spur social change. Out of necessity, the black church had to minister to the whole person. Out of necessity, the black church rarely had the luxury of separating individual salvation from collective salvation. It had to serve as the center of the community's political, economic, and social as well as spiritual life; it understood in an intimate way the biblical call to feed the hungry and clothe the naked and challenge powers and principalities. In the history of these struggles, I was able to see faith as more than just a comfort to the weary or a hedge against death; rather, it was an active, palpable agent in the world.
Beautifully said.
Reply With Quote
  #33  
Old 05-30-2011, 09:25 PM
Wonderment Wonderment is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Southern California
Posts: 5,694
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Collective salvation is not a tenant of Christianity it's a tenant of Marxism.
Really? I thought it was a tenet (not tenant) of Judaism. A tenant of Judaism would be a guy who rents a room in the shul basement.

In any case, Judaism is all about collective salvation. The "Let my people go" thang. Maybe that's Obama's dark secret: he's not a Muslim-Indonesian-Keynan-Tribesman after all; he's a Jew.
__________________
Seek Peace and Pursue it
בקש שלום ורדפהו
Busca la paz y síguela
--Psalm 34:15
Reply With Quote
  #34  
Old 05-30-2011, 10:05 PM
handle handle is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 1,986
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wonderment View Post
Really? I thought it was a tenet (not tenant) of Judaism. A tenant of Judaism would be a guy who rents a room in the shul basement.

In any case, Judaism is all about collective salvation. The "Let my people go" thang. Maybe that's Obama's dark secret: he's not a Muslim-Indonesian-Keynan-Tribesman after all; he's a Jew.
...not that there's anything wrong with that!
__________________
"God is a metaphor for that which trancends all levels of intellectual thought. It's as simple as that." J. Campbell

Last edited by handle; 05-30-2011 at 10:33 PM..
Reply With Quote
  #35  
Old 05-30-2011, 08:35 PM
graz graz is offline
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 3,162
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Wow. Can't a Mormon get a break from Amy. Isn't Harry Reid a Mormon? If electability were so intrinsically tied to identification with a given faith ... Well, we might have to introduce an amendment separating church and state or something.

Last edited by graz; 05-30-2011 at 08:45 PM..
Reply With Quote
  #36  
Old 05-30-2011, 10:21 PM
handle handle is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 1,986
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by graz View Post
Wow. Can't a Mormon get a break from Amy. Isn't Harry Reid a Mormon? If electability were so intrinsically tied to identification with a given faith ... Well, we might have to introduce an amendment separating church and state or something.
Is that what it says?
__________________
"God is a metaphor for that which trancends all levels of intellectual thought. It's as simple as that." J. Campbell

Last edited by handle; 05-30-2011 at 10:55 PM..
Reply With Quote
  #37  
Old 05-31-2011, 12:33 AM
chiwhisoxx chiwhisoxx is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 1,490
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by handle View Post
Is that what it says?
christine o'donnell clearly has no idea what the fuck she's talking about, but just for the record, there is a non-crazy reading of the establishment clause that's a bit more nuanced than "separation of church and state". this interpretation says the clause simply means the government cannot promote or denigrate any particular religion, and must allow everyone to practice any religion freely. o'donnell is wrong because creationism promotes a specific religious doctrine. but there's interesting court precedent to support this narrower reading of the establishment clause. there's a really interesting case involving a local government paying for transportation for kids being taken to private religious schools, i'll try and find it.
__________________
She said the theme of this party's the Industrial Age, and you came in dressed like a train wreck.
Reply With Quote
  #38  
Old 05-31-2011, 01:57 PM
handle handle is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 1,986
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by chiwhisoxx View Post
christine o'donnell clearly has no idea what the fuck she's talking about, but just for the record, there is a non-crazy reading of the establishment clause that's a bit more nuanced than "separation of church and state". this interpretation says the clause simply means the government cannot promote or denigrate any particular religion, and must allow everyone to practice any religion freely. o'donnell is wrong because creationism promotes a specific religious doctrine. but there's interesting court precedent to support this narrower reading of the establishment clause. there's a really interesting case involving a local government paying for transportation for kids being taken to private religious schools, i'll try and find it.
Why is religion treated any differently than any other for profit business, period?
I am not pleased with having to pay more taxes to offset the special tax exempt treatment these entities get, especially while they enjoy the privilege of having influence over voters and lawmakers. It's a crime.
__________________
"God is a metaphor for that which trancends all levels of intellectual thought. It's as simple as that." J. Campbell
Reply With Quote
  #39  
Old 05-31-2011, 02:22 PM
operative operative is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 3,261
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by handle View Post
Why is religion treated any differently than any other for profit business, period?
I am not pleased with having to pay more taxes to offset the special tax exempt treatment these entities get, especially while they enjoy the privilege of having influence over voters and lawmakers. It's a crime.
Churches have positive social capital--virtually every scholar on the subject agrees on that observation. Moreover, churches are not profit seeking institutions, the same as non-profit organizations which are also subjected to a different tax code. Would you support ending the different treatment of other non-profits, as well?
Reply With Quote
  #40  
Old 05-31-2011, 02:29 PM
handle handle is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 1,986
Default Re: Values Added: It's the Religion, Stupid (Amy Sullivan & Melinda Henneberger)

Quote:
Originally Posted by operative View Post
Churches have positive social capital--virtually every scholar on the subject agrees on that observation. Moreover, churches are not profit seeking institutions, the same as non-profit organizations which are also subjected to a different tax code. Would you support ending the different treatment of other non-profits, as well?
Yes. And no profit means no church. The overhead for a church is nothing but utilities, shelter, and what they decide to redistribute, they have no tangible product*, so all else is pure profit. When they do charity work, it is invariably coupled with shameless self promotion, and manipulation of the recipients.

*Except holy water, and various iconic charms and (action?) figures. (added)
__________________
"God is a metaphor for that which trancends all levels of intellectual thought. It's as simple as that." J. Campbell

Last edited by handle; 05-31-2011 at 02:33 PM..
Reply With Quote
 


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:14 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.