Bloggingheads Community

Bloggingheads Community (http://bloggingheads.tv/forum/index.php)
-   General comments on Bloggingheads.tv (http://bloggingheads.tv/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob (http://bloggingheads.tv/forum/showthread.php?t=7289)

badhatharry 01-16-2012 12:05 PM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Unit (Post 236860)
I had gotten the impression that there would be less diavlogs and yes a new comment section and a redesign, but I didn't expect the forum to be shut down. I'm ok with Disqus for the main page and the comments below the videos. I have nothing against that, but why should it affect the forum? That was not made clear. In fact, what we got is pretty much just as many diavlogs (if not more).

At the very least, Bob should have gotten his ducks in a row before he made his big announcement. How many diavlogs does it take to say that because of financial and logistical reasons the way bhTV operates is going to change significantly and here's how? He had three and still people came away confused.

Hemming and hawing is not productive or attractive but Bob does seem to do a lot of it.

graz 01-16-2012 12:38 PM

Falling on deaf ears?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by badhatharry (Post 236861)
At the very least, Bob should have gotten his ducks in a row before he made his big announcement. How many diavlogs does it take to say that because of financial and logistical reasons the way bhTV operates is going to change significantly and here's how? He had three and still people came away confused.

Hemming and hawing is not productive or attractive but Bob does seem to do a lot of it.

This! You offered a perfect encapsulation of the observable record.

He is a great interviewer, a fine writer, a thought provoking ideas man ... but the hemming and hawing manifest as whiny and irresolute. He's in desperate need of a producer or consultant. Having yes men sidekicks has not served him well. Evidenced by the reluctant Aryeh --who never quite sold the "yes Bob" routine-- to the eager new promoter JimM47. If only he'd listen to us badhat?

Please Bob, forever swear off commenter courts or klatches or any more extemporaneous offerings of your ideal vision of bhtv.

P.S. Disqus is a symptom as much as a disease.

stephanie 01-16-2012 01:18 PM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Unit (Post 236860)
I had gotten the impression that there would be less diavlogs and yes a new comment section and a redesign, but I didn't expect the forum to be shut down. I'm ok with Disqus for the main page and the comments below the videos. I have nothing against that, but why should it affect the forum? That was not made clear. In fact, what we got is pretty much just as many diavlogs (if not more).

I thought it was unclear what would happen with the forum, but in fact -- unless I missed something -- the forum hasn't been shut down.

look 01-16-2012 01:49 PM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
Stephanie said:
Quote:

The format is such that ongoing conversations about past diavlogs won't happen. The most recent one will get some feedback until the next one comes (or soon thereafter). With fewer diavlogs and the desire that all get comments, I strongly believe this is a benefit in the eyes of those who run the site. It also makes meaningful discussion unlikely to occur.
The disqus format is okay for a commenter with my short statement style, but I big-time saw the limitations of it when Ocean was commenting yesterday. Following the posts became like a dizzying merry-go-round.

But the bigger problem is the quoted. In the past, vlogs were like little jewels that could be savored by visiting them, referring to them, or linking to them from cached dingalinks.

Unit 01-16-2012 01:58 PM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by stephanie (Post 236863)
I thought it was unclear what would happen with the forum, but in fact -- unless I missed something -- the forum hasn't been shut down.

So why not let us run topic discussions here for each new diavlog without worrying about the bridge to the front page?

stephanie 01-16-2012 01:59 PM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by look (Post 236864)
I big-time saw the limitations of it when Ocean was commenting yesterday. Following the posts became like a dizzying merry-go-round.

Yes, I read through that after the fact, and it definitely demonstrated the limits. Really a shame.

The new format also makes it impossible to continue discussions or for new people to jump in after the fact (saving me some time today, I shouldn't complain). :-)

I think it would be beneficial to all -- assuming Bob doesn't want this forum to die and sees some credit to him and the site from the best discussions -- for there to be a way to continue discussions on the thread that go beyond the diavlog and into the topic or just go into the topic in great depth. Something like when it gets impossible to reply any more that it's acceptable to take it to this forum and a run-off thread. IMO, Bob et al. are just concerned that there are comments upfront. As long as how we use this forum isn't a competitor that interferes with that, I doubt they have an interest in 100 post long threads or discussions which continue well-past the posting of new diavlogs.

I doubt anyone from TPTB are reading here, but I think it would be worth talking through these issues and what we'd like and then presenting Bob et al. with a proposal that we think also serves his needs, as expressed.

look 01-16-2012 02:21 PM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
Quote:

I think it would be beneficial to all -- assuming Bob doesn't want this forum to die and sees some credit to him and the site from the best discussions -- for there to be a way to continue discussions on the thread that go beyond the diavlog and into the topic or just go into the topic in great depth. Something like when it gets impossible to reply any more that it's acceptable to take it to this forum and a run-off thread. IMO, Bob et al. are just concerned that there are comments upfront. As long as how we use this forum isn't a competitor that interferes with that, I doubt they have an interest in 100 post long threads or discussions which continue well-past the posting of new diavlogs
Agreed. It would be nice to simply switch here after the ninth level has been reached, but failing that, maybe after the DV falls off the main page (right-hand column) it could become fair game.

Unit 01-16-2012 02:22 PM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by stephanie (Post 236866)
Yes, I read through that after the fact, and it definitely demonstrated the limits. Really a shame.

The new format also makes it impossible to continue discussions or for new people to jump in after the fact (saving me some time today, I shouldn't complain). :-)

I think it would be beneficial to all -- assuming Bob doesn't want this forum to die and sees some credit to him and the site from the best discussions -- for there to be a way to continue discussions on the thread that go beyond the diavlog and into the topic or just go into the topic in great depth. Something like when it gets impossible to reply any more that it's acceptable to take it to this forum and a run-off thread. IMO, Bob et al. are just concerned that there are comments upfront. As long as how we use this forum isn't a competitor that interferes with that, I doubt they have an interest in 100 post long threads or discussions which continue well-past the posting of new diavlogs.

I doubt anyone from TPTB are reading here, but I think it would be worth talking through these issues and what we'd like and then presenting Bob et al. with a proposal that we think also serves his needs, as expressed.

What's TPTB?

stephanie 01-16-2012 02:50 PM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Unit (Post 236869)
What's TPTB?

The powers that be. Just a shorthand way of referring to whoever the decision makers are, same as "Bob et al."

badhatharry 01-16-2012 09:55 PM

Re: Falling on deaf ears?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by graz (Post 236862)
This! You offered a perfect encapsulation of the observable record.

I think...I might...just faint.

Don Zeko 01-17-2012 01:26 AM

Re: Falling on deaf ears?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by badhatharry (Post 236878)
I think...I might...just faint.

Strange New Respect!

Sulla the Dictator 01-17-2012 08:14 AM

Re: An Important Note to Our Valued Commenters from Bob
 
It seems there has already been a burst of new activity. My words of caution would be they seem to be very election focused, and largely Paulites. I question whether they can go the distance.

badhatharry 01-17-2012 11:17 AM

Re: Falling on deaf ears?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Don Zeko (Post 236881)

I was feeling so good and then you mentioned David Frum.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:51 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.